WeLovePetsSA

Smart Breeding: Making Smarter, Healthier Pairings

A dog carrying one copy of a variant linked to some recessive conditions may be healthy. Depending on the specific condition and the genetic status of the mate, careful pairing can help avoid affected puppies while retaining genetic diversity. Breeding choices should also consider the whole dog and its family history.

Modern breeders now have access to more information than ever before. They can screen for inherited diseases and use DNA testing to identify specific genetic variants. This information is valuable, but knowing a dog’s genetic status is only the first step.

Health testing is an essential part of any responsible breeding programme. Depending on the breed, it may include orthopaedic, cardiac, ophthalmic and hearing examinations, as well as DNA tests for known inherited conditions.

What Does a Genetic Test Result Mean for a Breeding Pairing?

It is important to note that a single health test should not be interpreted on its own, breeders should not simply be asking, “Is this dog clear?” but rather:

“What does this result mean and how should it affect which mate I pair with?”

Different genetic conditions are inherited in different ways, meaning that a particular result would make breeding inappropriate in one situation, but may be safely managed in another. Understanding the mode of inheritance is therefore just as important as the test result itself.

One of the clearest examples is a recessive genetic condition. A dog carrying one copy of a disease-associated variant may be completely healthy and show no signs of the condition. This is referred to as a carrier. In many recessive conditions, a dog generally needs to inherit two copies (one from each parent) to be affected.

A carrier therefore does not necessarily need to be removed from a breeding programme. For example, if a healthy carrier is bred to a dog that has tested clear for that recessive condition, the pairing can be planned to avoid producing affected puppies. The resulting puppies may include carriers, but the disease itself can be managed through testing and responsible breeding choices in subsequent generations.

Removing every carrier from a breed may seem like the safest approach, but it can also mean removing otherwise healthy, valuable genetic material from the population. This is important in breeds with relatively small gene pools.

Dachshund puppy

What Is a Gene Pool, and Why Does Genetic Diversity Matter?

Every breed has a gene pool. The total genetic variation available within that population. When breeders repeatedly select from a smaller group of dogs, genetic diversity can decrease and inbreeding can increase. This creates an important balancing act, in which a breeder wants to reduce the risk of known inherited diseases, but also needs to avoid narrowing the gene pool unnecessarily, to maintain genetic diversity.

There Is No Such Thing as a Genetically “Perfect” Dog

DNA testing has transformed breeding, but it is important to understand its limitations.

A dog that tests clear for a particular genetic condition does not have that condition; however, it does not mean that the dog is free from every inherited disease or every genetic variant that could potentially affect its offspring. Many inherited diseases also have complex modes of inheritance. Family history can therefore provide valuable information, particularly for conditions that cannot be identified through a simple genetic test.

A breeding decision should never be based on a single laboratory result. Factors such as overall health, temperament, structure and breed purpose all matter when choosing pairings. A dog may have an excellent genetic profile for the conditions tested but still be unsuitable for breeding because of other physical concerns. Conversely, a dog with one known genetic variant may still have many valuable qualities that could benefit the breed.

This is why breeders should consider the dog’s overall health, the mode of inheritance for the conditions it may have, as well as the health of its family and its proposed mate. These questions turn genetic testing into what it should be: a tool for making better breeding decisions.

Genetic diversity can also be affected by how frequently individual dogs are used. A highly successful male may have outstanding health, temperament and conformation, making him an attractive choice for breeders. However, if he is used excessively, his genes can become disproportionately represented in the breed. Responsible breeding therefore involves looking beyond the quality of an individual dog and considering how much genetic influence that dog is already having on the wider population.

Breeding Smarter, Not Simply “Clearer”

Genetic testing has given breeders an opportunity that previous generations did not have: the ability to identify specific genetic risks before making a mating. However, testing should not turn breeding decisions into a simple game of clear versus affected. A responsible breeder must use all the available information to ask what combination of dogs offers the healthiest and most sustainable outcome. Sometimes, that means excluding a dog from a breeding programme or even selecting a different mate. Sometimes, particularly with a recessive condition, it may mean retaining a healthy carrier and pairing it with an appropriate clear dog. Ultimately, responsible breeding is about managing risk, not pretending that risk can be eliminated completely.

The smartest mating is not necessarily the one between two dogs with the most “clear” results. It is the one where the breeder understands the risks, considers the whole picture and deliberately chooses a pairing that gives the next generation the best opportunity for a healthy future.

DISCLAIMER: This article is for educational purposes only and does not replace advice from a qualified veterinarian or animal geneticist. If you are planning a breeding programme or have concerns about inherited conditions in your dog, please speak to your vet and your breed club.

Where can I get genetic health tests done?

At ZooOmics, we provide both health and colour testing, as well as DNA profiles for both canine and feline. We utilise innovative technology for mutation testing and provide you with certificates for all testing done, which can be submitted to registrars and breed societies. For inquiries about sample collection, shipping, processing, and services, please contact us at [email protected]. Alternatively, visit our website at www.zooomics.co.za to download our sample submission form.

Facebook
LinkedIn
Scroll to Top