WeLovePetsSA

Logo Transparent white
Menu
Cute puppy with family

How to Choose an Ethical Dog Breeder

Choosing an ethical dog breeder means looking beyond available puppies, pedigrees or registration papers. A responsible breeder prioritises the health, welfare and temperament of their dogs, carefully plans each litter, carries out appropriate health screening, raises and socialises puppies responsibly, and remains committed to the dogs they breed throughout their lives.

If you have decided that a purpose-bred dog is right for you, knowing how to distinguish an ethical breeder from irresponsible breeding practices can help you make an informed choice—and avoid supporting breeding that puts profit or convenience ahead of animal welfare.

This guide explains the characteristics of an ethical dog breeder, the standards responsible breeders should follow, the questions you should ask before buying a puppy and the warning signs to look out for.

What Is an Ethical Dog Breeder?

An ethical dog breeder puts the health, welfare and long-term wellbeing of their dogs ahead of convenience or profit. They make considered breeding decisions, use appropriate health screening, raise puppies with proper care and socialisation, provide prospective owners with transparent information, carefully select suitable homes and remain committed to the dogs they breed throughout their lives.

These principles are reflected in the current Kennel Union of Southern Africa (KUSA) Code of Ethics. Among other requirements for KUSA members who breed, the code calls for breeding functionally and clinically healthy dogs with appropriate temperament, prioritising the health and wellbeing of the progeny and the mother, and taking reasonable steps to reduce hereditary disease.

What Are the Characteristics of an Ethical Dog Breeder?

Ethical breeders can generally be recognised by their commitment to responsible breeding decisions, appropriate health testing, excellent animal care, puppy socialisation, transparency with prospective owners, careful placement of puppies and ongoing responsibility for the dogs they produce.

A responsible breeder should:

  1. Prioritise health, welfare and temperament over appearance or profit.
  2. Use appropriate breed-specific health and genetic testing when planning a mating.
  3. Carefully consider the health and suitability of both parents.
  4. Provide excellent nutrition, veterinary care, exercise and living conditions.
  5. Raise puppies in an environment that supports healthy physical and behavioural development.
  6. Socialise puppies appropriately before they leave for their new homes.
  7. Be transparent about health, pedigree and known problems within their dogs or bloodlines.
  8. Carefully screen prospective owners rather than simply selling to whoever can pay.
  9. Provide appropriate records, documentation and a clear contract.
  10. Offer ongoing support and remain concerned about the welfare of the dogs they have bred.

Health screening is particularly important. Different breeds have different inherited health risks, so there is no single test that makes every breeding dog “health tested.” Responsible breeders investigate conditions relevant to their particular breed and use available screening and genetic information when making breeding decisions. KUSA’s current Code of Ethics specifically requires its breeder-members to take reasonable steps to reduce hereditary disease, including researching bloodlines and using available health tests for diseases to which the breed is predisposed.

Litter of puppies resting with their mother

Ethical Dog Breeding Standards: What Responsible Breeders Do

1. They Provide a High Standard of Care

Ethical breeding starts with the dogs already in the breeder’s care, not with the puppies they hope to sell.

Dogs should have appropriate food and clean water, safe housing, exercise, social interaction, grooming where required and veterinary attention when needed.

The physical environment matters too. Prospective owners should pay attention to where the dogs and puppies live. It should be clean, appropriate for the animals and provide opportunities for normal interaction and development.

KUSA’s Code of Ethics places explicit welfare responsibilities on its members and requires breeder-members to breed with the health and wellbeing of both the progeny and the bitch in mind.

2. They Prioritise Health and Temperament

An ethical breeder’s goal should not simply be to produce puppies that look a particular way.

Breeding decisions should consider:

  • physical health;
  • inherited disease risk;
  • functional soundness;
  • temperament;
  • the health of the mother;
  • and the likely welfare of future puppies.

Responsible breeding cannot guarantee that a puppy will never develop a health problem. Genetics and health are more complicated than that.

What a responsible breeder can do is make informed breeding decisions designed to reduce avoidable risks. Health screening and DNA testing can provide different kinds of information about breeding dogs and inherited conditions.

3. They Use Appropriate Health Testing

Ask the breeder:

What health conditions occur in this breed, and what tests have you performed on the parents?

Then ask to see the results.

Don’t settle for:

“The vet says they’re healthy.”

A general veterinary examination and a breed-relevant hereditary health screening are not necessarily the same thing.

KUSA advises puppy buyers to obtain as much information as possible about the parents’ health status and specifically recommends asking for copies of both parents’ health-test results before paying a deposit.

ZooOmics Genetic Health Testing for Dogs

4. They Raise and Socialise Puppies Responsibly

Early experiences matter.

Puppies should be safely exposed to appropriate human interaction, normal household or environmental experiences and developmentally suitable opportunities to interact and learn.

They also need adequate time with their mother and littermates.

As of March 2026, KUSA’s Code of Ethics states that its member breeders should not, except in special circumstances, transfer a puppy from their care before eight weeks of age. Some puppies may remain with the breeder longer depending on breed and individual development.

So be cautious if a breeder is eager for you to collect a very young puppy.

5. They Are Transparent

A responsible breeder should welcome reasonable questions.

Where practical, prospective owners should be able to see where the puppies are being raised and meet the mother.

Don’t automatically regard the father’s absence as suspicious. The most suitable sire may belong to another breeder and live elsewhere; responsible breeding decisions should be based on suitability rather than convenience.

The breeder should be willing to discuss:

  • the health history of the parents;
  • relevant health-test results;
  • pedigree;
  • vaccinations and veterinary care;
  • known health concerns;
  • the reasons for choosing a particular mating;
  • how the puppies have been raised and socialised;
  • and what documentation you will receive.

Transparency should work both ways.

6. They Ask You Questions Too

One of the strongest signs of a responsible breeder is that you are being assessed as well.

Expect questions about your:

  • home;
  • family;
  • lifestyle;
  • previous dog experience;
  • working arrangements;
  • expectations of the breed;
  • plans for training and exercise;
  • and ability to care for the dog throughout its life.

A breeder who cares about where their puppies go should want to know whether you and the puppy are a good match.

Responsible-breeder guidance from both KUSA and the AKC specifically emphasises assessing whether prospective owners have the time, facilities and understanding necessary to care for the dog.

7. They Provide Documentation and a Clear Contract

Ask what documentation accompanies the puppy and read the contract before committing.

Depending on the circumstances, this may include:

  • registration documentation;
  • pedigree information;
  • veterinary and vaccination records;
  • microchip information;
  • health-test information;
  • conditions or restrictions relating to breeding;
  • responsibilities of breeder and owner;
  • and what happens if the dog needs to be returned or rehomed.

KUSA recommends that buyers receive the puppy’s veterinary booklet and says microchipping is mandatory for KUSA-registered dogs. Its current Code of Ethics also contains requirements around registration and informing new owners in writing where a registration certificate carries a breeder’s restriction.

8. They Remain Responsible for the Dogs They Breed

The breeder’s interest shouldn’t disappear when the money changes hands.

Responsible breeders should be a source of information and support throughout the dog’s life.

Ask:

What happens if, five years from now, I can no longer keep this dog?

The answer can tell you a great deal about the breeder.

Responsible-breeding guidance emphasises ongoing responsibility and support, including arrangements for dogs that can no longer remain with their owners.

What is a Backyard Breeder?

“Backyard breeder” is an informal term rather than a single legal or universally agreed definition.

It is commonly used to describe breeding in which dogs are produced without the level of planning, health screening, welfare safeguards, breed knowledge, puppy socialisation, owner screening or lifelong responsibility expected of a responsible breeder.

The important issue isn’t simply where somebody breeds dogs.

A litter raised at someone’s home isn’t automatically irresponsible, just as a professional-looking kennel isn’t automatically ethical.

Instead, look at the breeder’s actions and standards.

Be particularly cautious where puppies are produced primarily for sale with little evidence of health testing, responsible breeding decisions, appropriate socialisation, transparency or concern about where the puppies ultimately end up.

family visiting a dog breeder and asking questions meeting mother dog and puppies

Questions to Ask a Dog Breeder Before Buying a Puppy

Don’t be afraid to interview the breeder. A responsible breeder should expect informed prospective owners to ask questions.

Ask:

  1. Why did you choose this particular mating?
  2. What health problems occur in this breed?
  3. What health tests have been performed on both parents?
  4. May I see the actual health-test results?
  5. Can I meet the mother and see where the puppies are being raised?
  6. How have the puppies been socialised?
  7. What veterinary care have they received?
  8. At what age will the puppies leave for their new homes?
  9. What registration, pedigree, veterinary and microchip documentation will I receive?
  10. May I see the purchase contract before paying a deposit?
  11. How do you decide which puppy goes to which home?
  12. What support do you provide after I take my puppy home?
  13. What happens if I can no longer care for the dog?
  14. Can you provide references from owners of dogs from previous litters?

The breeder’s willingness and ability to answer these questions matters as much as the answers themselves.

Does KUSA Registration Mean a Breeder Is Ethical?

No. KUSA registration alone should not be treated as proof that a breeder is ethical or that a puppy will be healthy.

There is also an important distinction in terminology: KUSA explains that it registers dogs and kennel names, rather than “registering breeders” in the way the phrase is sometimes used. Breeders registering dogs with KUSA must be KUSA members and are bound by KUSA’s applicable rules and Code of Ethics.

KUSA itself tells puppy buyers that buying a KUSA-registered puppy is “no guarantee for success” and advises buyers to conduct their own research, including obtaining information about the health status and testing of the parents.

Registration is therefore one piece of information, not a substitute for due diligence.

Ask to see the parents’ registration documentation, investigate relevant health testing, assess how the dogs and puppies are cared for, ask questions about the breeding programme and read the breeder’s contract.

Adoption or an Ethical Breeder?

Adoption remains an important option for people looking to add a dog to their family, and many wonderful dogs are waiting for homes.

However, some families choose a purpose-bred dog because they are looking for greater predictability in characteristics such as size, temperament, working ability or suitability for a particular lifestyle or activity.

The important distinction shouldn’t simply be “adopt versus shop.”

It should also be:

Are my choices supporting responsible animal care and breeding—or practices that contribute to poor welfare and irresponsible breeding?

If you choose to buy a puppy, taking the time to find a responsible breeder is part of responsible pet ownership.

Take the Ethical Breeder Checklist With You

Finding the right breeder can feel overwhelming, particularly when you’re excited about bringing home a puppy.

We’ve created a FREE Ethical Breeder Checklist to help you work through the important questions before making your decision.

Use it when speaking to breeders, visiting puppies and reviewing health and registration information.

Get your FREE Ethical Breeder Checklist by Email.

Final Thought

A responsible breeder shouldn’t simply be trying to sell you a puppy.

They should be trying to determine whether their puppy belongs with you.

Take your time. Ask difficult questions. Request documentation. Research the breed’s health risks and don’t be pressured into paying a deposit before you’ve done your homework.

A puppy may be with you for well over a decade.

Choosing where that puppy comes from deserves more than a quick decision.

References

Facebook
LinkedIn
Scroll to Top